Earnestine's Heart and Sugar Co.


Price per serving

Starts at $3 per person.

Packages

Prices start at $425


About Earnestine's Heart and Sugar Co.

Earnestine's Heart and Sugar Co.

Owner

Earnestine’s Heart & Sugar Co. is an amazing online dessert studio, known for transforming classic Southern flavors into premium, modern indulgences. We specialize in elevated sweets—Biscoff blondies, gourmet banana puddings, Brookies, charcuterie-style dessert boxes, and curated seasonal menus. Every recipe is made in the kitchen by hand with small-batch precision, high-quality ingredients, and a signature creative twist. Whether it’s a dessert table, vendor market, or luxury event, our bakery brings unforgettable flavor and amazing presentation straight from our kitchen to your celebration. We provide what we want to receive!

We specialize in generations-old recipes, especially pecan pralines, Charleston chewies, and Charleston Benne Wafers. We also put a twist on traditional cupcakes, topping them with specialty items like our popular Charleston chewies, chewy Chocolate chip cookies, etc.


Services

Dessert types

  • Cakes
  • Candy and confections
  • Cupcakes
  • Donuts
  • Mini desserts
  • Pastries
  • Pies
  • Puddings and custards

Services offered

  • Bars & Buffets
  • Delivery
  • Dessert installations
  • Setup
  • Tastings

Dietary accommodations

  • Vegetarian

Earnestine's Heart and Sugar Co. packages

Sweethearts in Love Bar (Bronze Package)

Price$425

Description

144 treats to choose from. - 4 dessert options - 3 dozen of each item - Delivery and Set Up Included - Signs and Labels included

What’s included
  • Cupcakes with Premium Toppings
  • Traditional Banana Pudding
  • Biscoff Banana Pudding
  • Charleston Chewies
  • Charleston Benne Wafers
  • Tres Leches
  • Individual Cake Slices or Cake Trifles
  • Mini Sweet Potato Pies
  • Smores Cookie Bars
  • Strawberry Shortcake Shooters
  • Strawberry Crunch Cookies
  • Sugar Linzer Cookie Hearts
  • Smores Brookies
  • Mini Bundt Cakes
  • XO Strawberry Crunch Pudding (Custard Base)

The "I Do" Dessert Bar (Silver Package)

Price$750

Description

252 treats to choose from: - 7 dessert options - 3 dozen of each option - Styling with Stands and Risers - Themed Colors to Match Wedding Colors & Palette - Delivery, Set Up, and Menu Signs

What’s included
  • Cupcakes with Premium Toppings
  • Traditional Banana Pudding
  • Biscoff Banana Pudding
  • Charleston Chewies
  • Charleston Benne Wafers
  • Tres Leches
  • Individual Cake Slices or Cake Trifles
  • Mini Sweet Potato Pies
  • Smores Cookie Bars
  • Strawberry Shortcake Shooters
  • Strawberry Crunch Cookies
  • Sugar Linzer Cookie Hearts
  • Smores Brookies
  • Mini Bundt Cakes
  • XO Strawberry Crunch Pudding (Custard Base)

The Heart & Sugar Lux Bar (Gold Package)

Price$1,600

Description

576 treats to choose from: - 8 dessert options - 6 dozen of each item - Themed colors to match wedding colors palette - Risers, Acrylic Stands, Trays, etc. included - Full Set Up & Break Down - Custom Signage - Free Delivery

What’s included
  • Cupcakes with Premium Toppings
  • Traditional Banana Pudding
  • Biscoff Banana Pudding
  • Charleston Chewies
  • Charleston Benne Wafers
  • Tres Leches
  • Individual Cake Slices or Cake Trifles
  • Mini Sweet Potato Pies
  • Smores Cookie Bars
  • Strawberry Shortcake Shooters
  • Strawberry Crunch Cookies
  • Sugar Linzer Cookie Hearts
  • Smores Brookies
  • Mini Bundt Cakes
  • XO Strawberry Crunch Pudding (Custard Base)

Reviews

Write a review

4.5 out of 5

2 reviews

Write a review
  • Warmth and Cookies

    Verified review
    JessieJan 11

    The baker of Earnestine's Heart and Sugar Company is incredibly welcoming, providing an abundant variety of cookies for tasting, as well as banana pudding, and bread for the table. She puts maximum effort into every batch, and will not stand for anything less than premium quality. I would always be excited to collaborate with them, as any gathering catered by them is sure to have our guests leaving with full bellies and sugary memories.

  • Best place for sweets

    Verified review
    Tyler S.Jan 11

    Earnestine's Heart and Sugar Co. has the best sweets around. They have such a variety of desserts and they all are absolutely delicious. From biscoff banana pudding to homemade gourmet cookies to beautiful and delicious cakes and everything in between, Earnestine's comes through with all their desserts. I was very satisfied with their quality, care, and service, and highly recommend them for any event.

    Response from vendorJan 11, 2026
    Thank you so much for your kind words. It is our pleasure to serve.