Bitty Bagels

Bitty Bagels creates NYC-style mini bagels with a modern, artisan twist — hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and cold-fermented for unmatched flavor and texture. Fresh-delivered in Sarasota, our bite-sized bagels are perfect for weddings, brunches, showers, and celebrations of all kinds. From classic flavors like Everything and Sesame to seasonal creations, we make it easy to delight your guests with something fresh, local, and unforgettable. Beautifully packaged and ready to serve, Bitty Bagels brings a taste of New York to your special day.

We specialize in NYC-style mini bagels that deliver all the flavor and texture of a classic bagel in a perfect, bite-sized form. Every mini is hand-rolled, kettle-boiled, and cold-fermented for 24 hours, giving it that authentic chew and depth of flavor. Our rotating menu blends timeless favorites with seasonal, Instagram-worthy flavors, all baked fresh in Sarasota and delivered ready to serve. We focus on consistency, presentation, and a premium guest experience — making your event menu memorable and unique.